Butterfinger Peanut Butter Fudge
Old-Fashioned • Handcrafted • Gluten Free
Our Butterfinger Peanut Butter Fudge is the perfect blend of smooth, creamy peanut butter fudge and crunchy Butterfinger® candy pieces, creating a rich, nostalgic flavor candy lovers can’t resist.
Made the old-fashioned way, each batch starts with pure cane sugar and fresh cream, slow-cooked in traditional copper kettles. The fudge is then hand-poured onto a marble slab, carefully hand-paddled, and finished using time-honored techniques that have defined our craft for decades. Once set, each loaf is hand-sliced into generous ½-pound slices.
Our fudge does not melt, requires no refrigeration, and stays fresh for weeks when kept covered at room temperature — making it perfect for gifting, shipping, or savoring over time.
Why You’ll Love It
✔ Creamy peanut butter fudge loaded with Butterfinger® candy
✔ Made from scratch using traditional copper kettle methods
✔ Handcrafted and hand-sliced for quality and consistency
✔ Gluten free
✔ Shelf-stable and gift-ready
Product Details
• Net Weight: ½ lb slice
• Storage: Room temperature, keep covered
• Shelf Life: Weeks when stored properly
Contains: Dairy, Peanuts
Gluten Free
Online Special
Mix and match your favorite flavors — BUY 5 slices, GET the 6th slice FREE!
Our 10-Step Fudge-Making Process
Batching → Cooking → Pouring → Cooling → Creaming → Loafing → Setting → Cutting → Selling → Eating
